Header Logo
About Contact
← Back to all posts

The Tylenol debate: what’s missing

Sep 24, 2025
Connect

You’ve probably seen the new headlines about Tylenol use in pregnancy and the CDC’s updated concerns around its possible link to autism.

Here’s the thing: modern medicine has done wonders for us in some areas… and failed us in others. Which means it’s never as black and white as “always reach for the Tylenol” or “never touch it again.”

Like any decision in pregnancy, it comes back to weighing risks and benefits through the lens of your own situation and values.

If you’ve got a mild headache, maybe the more nurturing choice is water, rest, or a warm bath. If you’ve got a 103° fever that won’t break, that might be the moment when the benefits of Tylenol outweigh the risks. Both can be true.

And if you’ve taken Tylenol before? Please hear me — you didn’t fail. If you used it when you needed it, you did what you felt was best in that moment to protect your baby and yourself.

What matters most is that you don’t hand all your power over to a headline, a provider, or even the CDC. Recommendations are not law. They’re one piece of the puzzle.

Critical thinking matters. So does intuition. When you put those together, you’ll find the decision that’s right for you — even if it looks different than what your neighbor chooses.

This is the exact approach we take inside The Birth Prep Circle. We don’t hand you a checklist of do’s and don’ts. We give you the tools to navigate controversial, confusing, and often conflicting advice in a way that leaves you confident and grounded in your own choices.

And if you want to experience that for yourself, I’d love to invite you to our free workshop this Sunday: The Secret to Labor Land. We’ll cover what actually matters in birth prep (spoiler: it’s not just whether or not Tylenol is safe).

👉 Sign up here for free and get the Zoom link

Always in your corner,
💛 Kayla & Leslie

P.S. You deserve more than one-size-fits-all answers. Come join us Sunday and find the kind of birth prep that honors your body, your baby, and your intuition.

Responses

Join the conversation
t("newsletters.loading")
Loading...
Where did you even learn that?
We have a question for you. What is your very first memory of birth? Not your first pregnancy or the first birth book you read. Not the first childbirth class you took. But your very first memory of being introduced to the concept of birth. Maybe it was a movie scene with a woman screaming in a hospital bed while everyone ran around in a panic. Maybe it was hearing your mom tell the story of yo...
Our take on freebirth
We've been watching the conversations surrounding the recent death of Stacey Werneke, and before we say anything else, we want to acknowledge that regardless of the circumstances, a woman died and a family is grieving. Whatever conversations come from this tragedy, that reality deserves to stay at the center. Our hearts go out to her family and friends.  Like so many birth conversations, this o...
Is that evidence-based?
We hear the term "evidence based" all the time in the birth world, and for good reason. We love research. We read studies. We think having good evidence is one of the best tools we have when we're making decisions about pregnancy and birth. It improves the standard of care (albeit slowly) within the medical system. And it's why we recommend the Evidence Based Birth resource to almost all of our...

Sacred Reflections

More than tips and to-do lists — this is a soft landing place. A mix of stories, reflections, poems, playlists, and gentle invitations back to yourself. Rooted in evidence, intuition, and transformation, this offering is for anyone who believes birth is a rite of passage and wants to explore it with reverence and curiosity.
© 2026 Birth Alchemy, LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Get notified when our podcast launches!

From the nerdy scientific, evidence-based info, to the mystical woo-woo side of birth transformation - we're discussing it all. We can't WAIT to share these conversations with you.